What is the Best First Valentine’s Day Gift?

Valentine’s Day preparations can be pretty hectic if it’s your first time. Restaurant reservations filling up, store shelves swiped clean of chocolate boxes, and on top of that – finding a sweet gift for the lucky lady who’s caught your eye. For your first Valentine’s Day together, we recommend gifting simple and lovely jewelry that speaks from the heart.  

The easiest pick for Valentine’s Day is classic, timeless heart jewelry. Shop from an assortment of pretty gold bracelets for a touching gift that will get your feelings across (even if you haven’t said the “L” word yet!) If you’ve only been dating for a few months, this is a sentimental gift that says just enough about how happy you are to be with her. Choose from an engraved heart bracelet or a long modern heart charm bracelet.  

If you two have been dating for more than six months, then we recommend gifting from our crystal collection. These dazzling pieces are bold and unique – perfect for your love. Choose from cute peach crystal earrings or chic crystal necklaces for a piece she’ll turn to for any event. We’ve made it easy for you to give a present whose sleek design will make her shine. 

When in doubt, personalize it. Another favorite first Valentine’s Day gift is a necklace engraved with her initial. Engraving with her monogram may be more formal, but we love the look of our Willow Layering Set and Margot Layering Set with just one beautiful letter. Customizing a necklace through brook & york is a great way to elevate a gift without breaking the bank.